Elections Ontario commits to responding within 10 days
Elections Ontario spent $4.83 million during 2014 election campaign on voter information and ads that all missed key messages to encourage voter turnout – turnout was second lowest level ever at 51.3%
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Thursday, March 8, 2018
OTTAWA – Today, Democracy Watch released the lawyer’s letter it sent on Tuesday to Ontario’s Chief Electoral Officer Greg Essensa demanding that he confirm that Elections Ontario will inform voters about their legal right to decline their ballot (in other words, to vote “none of the above”) in the likely more than $4.5 million it will spend on advertising and communications with voters leading up to Ontario’s provincial election day on June 7th.
Democracy Watch is represented by Andrew Spurgeon and Wade Poziomka of Ross McBride LLP, who sent the letter to CEO Essensa yesterday. The letter gives CEO Essensa 10 days to respond and commit to include the information in ads and voter education communications or Democracy Watch will apply for a court order. Democracy Watch hopes Elections Ontario will make the commitment and avoid a court case.
On Wednesday, Elections Ontario sent a letter saying it will respond formally to Democracy Watch’s request within 10 days.
“Elections Ontario has a broad mandate that allows education on the right to vote and the electoral process. Elections Ontario has exercised their discretion to educate Ontarians and will spend approximately $4.5 million taxpayer dollars,” said Wade Poziomka. “That decision, and the content of that education, should be fair and reasonable. This includes not only education on the right to vote, but education on the right to decline a ballot and not be forced to vote for a listed candidate. A voter has the right to show their lack of support for any candidate or political party and still be counted as having cast a vote. It is our hope that a protracted and costly legal battle will not be necessary and Elections Ontario will exercise their statutory discretion in a fair and reasonable manner.”
“Democracy Watch calls on Elections Ontario to do the right thing and commit to informing voters in all its advertising and voter education information that they have the legal right to vote none of the above by declining their ballot in the provincial election, and if they don’t we will apply for a court order,” said Duff Conacher, Co-founder of Democracy Watch. “Some voters may not support any party that has a candidate in their riding or may not support any of the parties’ platforms, and they have the right to be informed by Elections Ontario that they have the right to vote for ‘none of the above’ by declining their ballot.”
Ontario voters have the legal right under section 53 of Ontario’s Election Act to decline their ballot (i.e. vote “none of the above”) and have it counted separately from a vote for a candidate or a spoiled ballot. This right has existed in the law since 1975. However, Elections Ontario has consistently failed to inform voters that they have this right in its communications to educate voters undertaken under subsection 114.1(2) and section 114.2 of the Election Act.
On January 8th, Democracy Watch sent a similar letter to CEO Essensa, and Elections Ontario immediately changed three pages of its website by adding information about the right to decline your ballot. On January 12, 2018, Kate Ward, Director of Communications and Strategic Services at Elections Ontario, sent a letter to Democracy Watch pointing to the changes to the website.
That same day Democracy Watch wrote back to Elections Ontario applauding the changes to the website but asking for a commitment to include information about the right to decline your ballot in all advertising and communications with voters, and requesting answers to the following questions:
- Will all Elections Ontario advertisements before and during the upcoming election campaign period that are about voter rights contain information about the right to decline your ballot?
- Will Election Ontario’s voter registration cards and any other materials Elections Ontario sends to Ontario voters in the lead up to the provincial election mention the right to decline your ballot?
- Will all of Elections Ontario’s online and print educational materials for teachers, youth, and new voters be changed to include information, in all sections concerning voting, that voters have the right to decline their ballot?
Elections Ontario did not respond to Democracy Watch’s January 12th message, forcing Democracy Watch to follow up with the demand letter it sent on Tuesday.
Despite Elections Ontario’s $4.5 million in advertising spending in 2011, voter turnout in the 2011 Ontario election was a record low 48.2% of eligible voters, the first time in history that turnout dropped below 50%. And despite Elections Ontario’s more than $4.8 million in ad spending in 2014, turnout in the 2014 election was the second-lowest ever at 51.3%. The 2007 turnout was only slightly better at 52.1%.
Elections Ontario currently mentions the right to decline your ballot only the few times on its website that were added on January 8th. In its 2011 and 2014 election advertising, website pages, new voter information package, and voter information card, Elections Ontario failed to mention the right to decline your ballot.
Democracy Watch has long called on the federal government, and every provincial and territorial government, to change their election laws (including the law for municipal elections in each jurisdiction) and add the right to vote “none of the above” and to give a reason to election and by-election ballots.
– 30 –
FOR MORE INFORMATION, CONTACT:
Duff Conacher, Co-founder of Democracy Watch
Democracy Watch’s Democratic Voting System Campaign